Like so many RIM – Research in Motion – BB users, last week’s worldwide Blackberry outage was a big inconvenience for me. I was traveling and even more reliant on the efficacy of BB’s email platform. A by-product was that for whatever reason the lack of messages was somehow combined with a fast depletion of my battery power so that for a time I could not even make telephone calls. Thoughts of iPhones and Androids were dancing before my eyes.
I’ve been a BB user for more than ten years. Most of us that are BB aficionados defend the lousy platform as being acceptable because the email is excellent as is the telephone. Conversely BB web browsing is slow and clumsy and the Apps are the worst of any of the smartphones.
I was with a friend on Sunday and he too claimed to have been a BB addict for almost fifteen years. He now has an iPhone and has for the past year. He noted that the iPhone telephone is terrible but email was ok, but his most interesting observation is the iPhone is a small version of an iPad. That something I’ve not heard anyone say that before.
My friend also noted that in 2010 at a friend’s daughter’s sorority rush all the ‘sisters’ have to throw their mobile devices into a pile and cannot use them during rush. Of the 38 devices 37 were Blackberrys. This did not surprise me as my own daughter who is a freshman this year has a BB and her primary reason for getting one was the BB Messenger service – immediate and ‘free’ texting. However he added that this year in 2011 of the 35+ phones – only one of them was a BB and the rest were iPhones. In his opinion BB is already dead since once the younger set rejects the BB platform they are truly going to be toast.
BB has been espousing its new forthcoming operating system (QNX – pronounced CUE-nix) including an entire new generation of Blackberrys. We’ve all seen what a disaster the BB Playbook tablet has turned out to be. So to say I am skeptical would be an understatement. The New York Times had an article about Blackberry today – http://nyti.ms/pp1J93 – I did not know whether to be optimistic or pessimistic after I read it.
Another friend of mine last week showed me his BB Torch (he is an email junkie like me) as well as his new Samsung Android i997 – a big touch screen, thin and fast web-browsing smartphone. And it was only $ 99. For him carrying two devices makes sense. I don’t think I could carry two phones around with me all the time.
As usual whenever I write about Blackberry, or any non-Apple platform all the Apple acolytes chime in that I am totally missing the boat. They say that the iPhone (particularly with the new 4S and Siri – a true world phone they aver) is the only way to go. However I also hear snippets that iPhone email can be problematic and that the phone is the weak link, while the Apps are fantastic and web-browsing is great. Since I primarily use my smartphone for email, telephone calls and THEN web-browsing and Apps, I remain unconvinced.
I too am battling against all my friends who carry iPhones, I did however, make the recent mistake of ditching my BB after more than 10 years for a sumsung wave! I just thought, ‘maybe I need a change?’ Boy was I wrong……. I realized that I relied on the BB for email (via 5 accounts) and voice calls – to me web browsing or apps, just doesn’t come into my working day, but when I’m not getting email on-the-hope it really frustrates me and drives me close to insane. I too am put off the iPhone by the comments of bad phone calls, I when thinking about all the friends who have iPhones and what they say – 99% of them comment about apps, camera and ???None tell me how good the email or call elements are. So, do I go back to BB?
Thanks for your comment Chris. I do feel much the same. Have you considered the two device option?
The BB is dead, I buried mine over a year ago.
My android does e-mail just as well as my BB did, is an excellent phone, and has all the extras you want from a modern smartphone. The people I know with iphones seem to feel the same way, the early ones had issues with poor phone quality but I have not heard of that problem since the early versions.