How the NCAA is like the Chinese Government

The National Collegiate Athletic Association was officially constituted in 1906 and took its present name in 1910. It was the flying wedge, football’s major offense in 1905 that spurred the formation of the NCAA. In its early years the NCAA was primarily a discussion group and rules oriented group, but in 1921 (source – – ) the first NCAA championship was held.

In the years since its founding college sports have become a huge money making business. And big money is earned for the universities, for television and radio networks, and for the officials that make up the governing body of the NCAA itself. Current NCAA President Mark A. Emmert (named April 27, 2010), has a base salary of well over $ 500,000 annually. So it follows that the NCAA governing body brass is a well-paid bunch. They do not want to give up power. Sound familiar?

Two weeks ago Auburn quarterback and Heisman trophy winner Cam Newton was ruled eligible to continue playing despite the fact that reportedly his father had been involved in a ‘pay-for-play’ scheme. This was apparently unbeknownst to his son.

USC athletic director Pat Haden told The Los Angeles Times that he was surprised by the NCAA’s ruling on Newton. USC was hit with sanctions this past summer in the wake of the Reggie Bush investigation. (Full disclosure – I am a USC alumni) “In the Reggie Bush case, when the parent [did] something inappropriate the kid and the school suffered,” Haden told The Times.

Bush returned the Heisman Trophy and the school was hit with a postseason ban, scholarship reductions and probation after the NCAA found that Bush and his parents accepted extra benefits from agents and sports marketers when Bush was at USC.

For the record I am not unhappy that Mr. Newton remained eligible to compete. I do feel that the two situations are not at all dissimilar but the response from the NCAA is inequitable.
How is the NCAA like the Chinese Government? For one thing both have a bunch of old-timers who are trying their hardest to hold onto their power when the world around them is changing rapidly. The Chinese government response to Nobel Prize winner Liu Xiaobo’s situation reminded me of how the NCAA handles things. The both handle things heavy-handedly and without equanimity.

And yet I believe that even the Chinese government is changing slowly, (but for the better) at a greater rate than is the NCAA. At least it seems as if the Chinese government is conscious of the world outrage at them disallowing one of their own citizens to go and collect one of the highest honors awarded on the planet.

The NCAA’s refusal to consider ‘pay-for-play’ athletes is evidence that they simply are not in touch with what is going on. Seventeen and eighteen year old athletes like Reggie Bush and Cam Newton help contribute millions of dollars to their universities, their cities, and the NCAA itself. They take a huge risk in doing so from the standpoint that an injury could end their careers and thus their earning potential as an athlete. Offering them a four year education and room and board is not a fair trade.

I say give them a four year education that they can use at any time and ask them to be enrolled in one class at the university for the time that they are participating in an NCAA sport. Pay them a salary – a decent salary. This way when a wealthy alumni comes along and offers to take care of the athlete’s parents by buying them a house they will have reason to resist an irresistible temptation. Think about it. Could you really pass on taking care of your parents if you had the means and opportunity?

To me it’s a sad commentary when the socialist government of China and an organization like the NCAA cannot be seen as being ideologically that far apart. True the NCAA has not gone out and ‘eliminated’ dissenters as the Chinese government has done but somehow I have a belief that things will change in China before they do in the NCAA.

What do you think?

About markkolier

Futurist, entrepreneur, left lane driver, baseball lover
This entry was posted in Living in the World Today, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to How the NCAA is like the Chinese Government

  1. Zeitung says:

    Who will get the trophy after Auburn has to return those games and the NC?


  2. AG says:

    While your post is provocative, a few key questions for you Mark:

    – you reference the NCAA website. Did you read the material on the cases you cite which lay out the differences? There are core differences that undermines your entire contention.

    – can you remind me where the Chinese government distributes it’s money? The NCAA cites that some 96 cents of every dollar go to it’s membership and the balance is used for championships and other services. Setting aside your bizarre Chinese government reference, how many other organizations distribute 96 percent of earnings?

    – I’m trying to find where in your column you explain that the rules the NCAA enforces including the penalties are established entirely by its membership — the very schools that are being penalized in the cases you reference.

    For such an experienced and intelligent person, your column ignore the facts and as someone who benefitted as a former student-athlete in a non-revenue sport, its bothersome that you would ignore basic facts that make piling on so easy… And flat out wrong.


    • markkolier says:

      I appreciate your well thought out comment. In a short blog post I chose to not describe rules and distribution of money by the NCAA. My overall point was that the NCAA administration acts without impunity and is running the organization the same way it has done for decades. I’m not saying the NCAA is all bad (nor is the Chinese government for that matter), just that it’s time that they allow changes to their protocols to take place.


  3. mochamom says:

    Profit vs. privilege…It is modern day slavery of Black men…Work for free while someone else makes the money..but oh yeah we will feed you and teach you how to read and write…wow…Just think about it..if the majority of the players were white bringing in half of the money these institutions/ the NCAA are receiving…this would be a no brainer…the young white student athletes would have their privilege and their profits….common sense…everyone wants to tip toe around the real issue of race…just admit it America…racism still exists…it just has a different face…


  4. mochamom says:

    BTW…what the heck is Mark Emmert doing with a half a million dollars…he gets paid more than the president…he lives a good life off the blood, sweat and injuries of these young men….wow


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.